Punishments
There are several reasons punishments (including spanking, time out and “consequences” when they presented punitively) are mistakes. The most crucial is that children who are taught through physical or emotional pain tend to stop trusting us and themselves. Expecting humans at their most vulnerable stage of life to learn through pain and shame (when healthy adults would never put up with this) doesn’t make a lot of sense, does it? Can you imagine taking a college course and being spanked or banished to “time out” because you weren’t learning quickly enough?
Even if punishments didn’t have long term negative effects, the truth is they don’t work. The loving, trusting bond our children have with us is what makes following our code of behavior and internalizing our values something they want to do. Erode that relationship, and discipline becomes an “us against them” struggle.
Perceiving children as “bad” rather than in need of help
There was a toddler in one of my parent/toddler guidance classes whose behavior could be considered “bad”. He was compelled to push limits, probably because his adoring, gentle mother struggled to set them confidently. She admitted that his behavior unnerved her. That, in turn, unnerved him, and “acting out” was the way he demonstrated it.
Some days I would have to calmly follow this boy, shadowing him so that he wouldn’t push or tackle one of the other 18-24 month olds. When I sensed an aggressive impulse coming, I would place my hand in the way and say matter-of-factly, “I won’t let you push” or gently move him away from the friend he was tackling and say, “That’s too rough.”
There was no point in reminding him to touch gently (in fact, that would have been an insult to his intelligence). He knew exactly what ‘gentle’ meant and was clearly making a different choice. But what I would often end up asking was, “Are you having a hard time today?” “Da”, he’d answer a bit wistfully, a hint of a smile on his face, recognition in his eyes. This simple acknowledgement coupled with my calm, consistent limit setting would usually ease the behavior.
Toddlers love to be understood. They also need to know that their discipline “teachers” are calm, unruffled and understanding, not thrown or upset by their behavior. And that is the way that I have come to understand misbehavior. It is not intentionally bad, mean or a way to upset parents. It is a request for help.
Help me, I’m tired. Help me, I have low blood sugar. Help me stop hitting my friends. Help me stop annoying or angering you… better yet, stop me before I do those things. Help me by remaining calm so I sense how capable you are at taking care of me. Help me by empathizing, so that I know you understand and still love me. Help me so that I can let go of these urges and distractions and be playful, joyful and free again.
I don’t usually reblog children-things, but this is important.
Part of the issue is our cultural toolbox for dealing with problems is woefully understocked. Right now its almost entirely punitive. Many parents just aren’t equipped with the tools to enforce without punishment. We, as a culture, need to fix this. We need to give these parents the de-escalation skills and alternative methods to punishment for dealing with kids, to prevent that adversarial dynamic between child and parents.
Question: My approach has generally been to redirect if it’s “an acceptable” (read: nonviolent) breach of boundaries, but if the toddler hits/bites/tackles/kicks/etc someone else or tries to use a toy to hurt someone, they are removed from the situation or the toy is taken away. So if im at the park with the toddler I’m watching, and she is yanking another kids’ pigtails she will get a warning and asked if they’re hungry or tired or thirsty. And if it happens again, we leave. If she uses a toy to try to hit someone, the same thing, a warning, a check in, and if she continues then I take it away for a period of time. Would this still be considered punitive? If someone brought me somewhere with them and I was going around hurting other people, I think that person would be within their right to remove me from that situation. And if I was using a toy or my bag to try to hurt someone else, I think someone else would be within their right to take it from me so that I can’t continue to use it to hurt others. I will note that this same child will be mostly respectful of boundaries with me during the day, but when I first get to the house, she will continuously scream “NO” and even approach me to try to hit me. When her mom comes home she will be overcome with joy and then suddenly become very upset and start pushing all the boundaries she knows she’s not supposed to, including hitting me or being generally destructive and throwing things to the ground and refusing to help pick them up. The household is a strictly
Apparently she pushes boundaries with her mom all the time and refuses to take any naps for anyone but me, tho she was always stubborn about sleep. Apparently I’m the most consistent with her so that’s probly a factor but her mom is quite patient and calm with her. With her aunt who is probably second most consistent, she has bitten her and taken gouges out of her face with her nails. She’s unpredictable. She’ll be laughing and suddenly lash out and glare at you.
I’m genuinely curious what the appropriate response would be within this method of approach



















